WhatsBusted
Symptom

Water heater smells like rotten eggs

First question: is the smell in the air, or in the hot water? A smell in the air near a gas water heater can be a gas leak. Leave first, read later.

Check these first

Five-minute checks, no tools

  • In the air? Leave now

    If you smell rotten eggs in the air near a gas water heater or other gas appliance, even faintly, do not touch switches. Leave the house and call 911 or your gas utility from outside.

  • Hot only, or cold too?

    Run a cold tap, then a hot one, and smell each. Hot only points to the water heater. Both point to your water supply.

  • Well or softened water?

    The smell needs sulfate in the water. Well water and softened water are often involved, so note which you have. It helps a pro pick the right fix.

Likely causes

Ranked by how often they are the problem

  1. 1

    Gas leak

    Call a pro

    A rotten egg smell in the air near a gas appliance. This is an emergency. Leave the house and call 911 or your gas utility from outside. Do not try to find the leak yourself.

  2. 2

    Bacteria reacting with the anode rod

    DIY fix

    Only the hot water smells. Swapping the anode rod for one made of a less active metal, often aluminum in place of magnesium, then disinfecting the tank and hot water lines, may help. Never just remove the rod: the tank then rusts.

    Fix the anode rod45 min–2 hr$20–$75
  3. 3

    Sulfur in the water supply

    Call a pro

    The cold water smells too. The sulfur is coming in with the water. A water treatment pro can test it and set up treatment, such as continuous chlorination and filtering.

What's happening

What your water heater is doing

If you smell it in the air near a gas water heater, treat it as a gas leak. Gas has no smell of its own. Gas companies add an odorant that smells like rotten eggs so you notice a leak, so even a faint smell counts. Do not light anything, do not touch light switches, and do not use a phone inside. Get everyone out, then call 911 or your gas utility from outside or a neighbor's phone. Do not go back in until they say it is safe.

If the smell is only in your hot water, it is not gas. It is hydrogen sulfide made inside the tank. Bacteria that live in water with sulfate in it, and little oxygen, turn that sulfate into the smelly gas. The anode rod, which corrodes on purpose to protect the tank, gives them the extra hydrogen they need.

Water heater makers say these bacteria are not harmful to people. It is still worth fixing, and if you have any doubt about your water, your local health department can tell you how to get it tested.

Run the cold water too. If only the hot water smells, the heater is making the smell. If the cold water smells as well, the problem is in your water supply, and the heater is not the main cause.

Know your limits

When to call a pro

Stop and call a pro if

  • You smell rotten eggs or gas in the air near a gas appliance. Leave the house and call 911 or your gas utility from outside.
  • The hot water still smells after a new anode and disinfecting the tank. A water treatment pro can test your water.
  • The cold water smells too. The cause is in your water supply.

FAQ

Common questions

Is rotten egg smelling hot water dangerous?

Water heater makers say the bacteria behind it are not harmful to people. A smell in the air near a gas appliance is a different matter. Treat that as a gas leak and leave.

How do I tell a gas leak from smelly water?

Smelly water only smells when the hot water runs, at the tap. Gas smells in the air, with no water running, often strongest near the appliance. Some gas is heavier than air and settles low, so smell near the floor too. If you are not sure, leave and call 911 or the gas utility from outside.

Can I just take out the anode rod?

No. The anode rod is what keeps the steel tank from rusting. Without it, the tank corrodes and leaks. Swap it for a rod of a different metal instead.

Does it matter if I have a well?

It can. The smell needs sulfate in the water, and well water is often involved. If changing the anode does not fix it, a water treatment pro can test your water and treat the supply.

Related

Keep going