WhatsBusted
Symptom

Water heater rumbling or popping

That gravelly rumble is usually not a sign of doom. It is most often mineral sediment on the bottom of the tank, and a flush often quiets it.

Check these first

Five-minute checks, no tools

  • Listen while it heats

    Run some hot water so the heater starts heating, then listen. Sediment noise comes while the burner or elements are on and fades when they shut off.

  • Look for water at the base

    Check the floor and the base of the tank for water. A hiss with a puddle is a leak, not sediment. See [water heater leaking](/water-heater/symptoms/leaking).

  • Check the relief valve pipe

    Look at the end of the pipe that runs down from the valve near the top of the tank. If it is dripping or spraying hot water, the tank may be overheating or over pressure. Call a pro.

  • Gas heater just filled?

    A new gas heater, or one just refilled with cold water, often sizzles as condensation drips onto the burner. That is normal and stops once the tank is hot.

Likely causes

Ranked by how often they are the problem

  1. 1

    Sediment on the tank bottom

    DIY fix

    The most common cause on both gas and electric heaters. A drain valve flush clears loose sediment and, in many cases, the noise with it.

  2. 2

    Scale on the lower element

    DIY fix

    Electric heaters only. Scale on the element makes it rumble, hiss or sizzle while it heats. A scaled element can be removed and cleaned, or replaced. See heating element.

    Fix the element1 hr–3 hr$10–$60
  3. 3

    Condensation on a cold tank

    DIY fix

    Gas heaters only. Burning gas makes water vapor that condenses on a cold tank and drips onto the burner with a sizzle. It is common on a new heater filled with cold water, and fades once the tank is hot.

  4. 4

    Hardened scale a flush will not clear

    Call a pro

    After years without flushing, some deposits are too hard or stubborn for a flush to move, and the rumbling stays. A pro can delime the tank with a product made for drinking water systems, or tell you it is time to replace it.

What's happening

What your water heater is doing

Hard water carries dissolved minerals. As the water heats, some of them settle out and collect on the bottom of the tank as sediment and scale.

On a gas heater, the burner heats the tank from underneath. Water trapped under the sediment layer flashes to steam and bubbles up through it. That is the popping and rumbling you hear while the burner runs.

On an electric heater, the lower element sits near the bottom where sediment collects. Scale on the element, or sediment around it, can make it rumble, hiss or sizzle while it heats.

The noise itself does no harm, but the sediment behind it does. Heat has to pass through the layer, so the heater works harder. On electric models, sediment that reaches the lower element can make it fail early.

Know your limits

When to call a pro

Stop and call a pro if

  • You smell gas. Do not touch any switches. Leave the house and call your gas utility from outside.
  • The relief valve or its pipe is dripping or spraying hot water. Never cap or plug it.
  • The noise is still there after a full flush.
  • Water is pooling around the base of the tank, or dripping keeps going after the tank is hot.

FAQ

Common questions

Is a rumbling water heater dangerous?

Usually not on its own. Sediment noise is a maintenance warning. It costs you efficiency, and on electric models it can shorten element life. The time to worry is if the relief valve starts discharging or water appears at the base. Then call a pro.

Will flushing stop the noise?

In many cases, yes. A flush clears loose sediment. Years of hardened scale may not budge, though. If the noise is the same after a good flush, a pro can delime the tank or help you decide whether it is time to replace it.

How often should I flush my water heater?

Follow your manual first. Without other advice, about once a year is a common rule of thumb, and more often if you have hard water. See drain valve and tank flush for how.

Why does my new gas water heater sizzle?

Burning gas makes water vapor. When the tank is full of cold water, that vapor condenses on the tank and drips onto the burner. It stops once the water is hot. If the dripping keeps going, check for a leak.

Related

Keep going