WhatsBusted
3D model of a water heater
Symptom

Water heater keeps tripping the breaker

A breaker that trips is doing its job: something is drawing current where it should not. On an electric water heater, the usual suspect is a heating element that has shorted to the tank, and you can test for that yourself.

Check these first

Five-minute checks, no tools

  • Any burning smell or scorch marks?

    Check the panel and the heater. If you smell burning, see scorch marks, or the breaker feels hot, leave it off and call an electrician.

  • Look for water

    Check the floor, the tank, the top fittings and around the access panels. Water reaching the wiring can trip the breaker. If you find a leak, leave the power off.

  • Breaker or reset button?

    Make sure it is really the breaker at the panel that is off. If the panel is fine but there is no hot water, the red reset button on the heater may have tripped instead.

  • Reset the breaker once, then watch

    If nothing above looks wrong, switch the breaker fully off, then on, one time. Note whether it trips right away or after the heater runs a while. If it trips again, leave it off.

Likely causes

Ranked by how often they are the problem

  1. 1

    Heating element shorted to the tank

    DIY fix

    One of the most common causes. An element that has grounded to the tank trips the breaker, often as soon as it gets power. The short-to-tank test on the element page finds it in a few minutes. Test both elements.

    Fix the element1 hr–3 hr$10–$60
  2. 2

    Loose or burned wiring

    Call a pro

    A loose terminal screw on an element or thermostat heats up, scorches the wire and can arc or short. Wires inside the heater that rub against metal can short too. Scorched or melted wiring or burned terminals are an electrician's job.

  3. 3

    Water reaching the wiring

    Call a pro

    A leak from the tank, a fitting or the relief valve can drip into the electrical parts. Fix the leak first. See water heater leaking.

  4. 4

    Breaker worn out or too small

    Call a pro

    An aging breaker can trip on a normal load, and one that is undersized trips even when the heater works fine. Never swap in a bigger breaker yourself. It is sized to protect the wiring.

What's happening

What your water heater is doing

An electric water heater runs on its own 240 V double breaker. Two heating elements inside the tank take turns heating the water, and each one pulls a lot of current while it runs.

When an element's heating wire breaks through its metal sheath and touches the tank, current takes a shortcut to ground. In most cases the breaker sees that and trips. This is one of the most common reasons a water heater breaker trips.

Other things cause the same trip: a loose or burned wire inside the panel covers, water from a leak reaching the wiring, wiring that rubs where it should not, or a breaker that is worn out or too small for the heater.

This is different from the red reset button on the heater itself. That button trips when the water gets too hot. The breaker trips on an electrical fault. Sometimes the same bad element causes both.

Know your limits

When to call a pro

Stop and call a pro if

  • You smell burning, see scorch marks, or the breaker is hot or will not reset. Leave it off and call an electrician.
  • It trips again after you have tested both elements and found no short. Do not keep resetting it.
  • Anyone suggests a bigger breaker to stop the tripping. The breaker protects the wiring, and upsizing it is a fire risk.
  • Wires inside the heater are melted, scorched or have bare spots.
  • Water is leaking onto the electrical parts or from the tank itself.

FAQ

Common questions

Is it safe to keep resetting the breaker?

No. Reset it once to see what happens. If it trips again, something is wrong, and a breaker that keeps tripping is protecting you from it. Leave it off until you find the cause.

Is the breaker the same as the reset button on the water heater?

No. The breaker is in your electrical panel and trips on an electrical fault. The red reset button is on the heater's thermostat and trips when the water gets too hot. A grounded element can set off either one.

Can I test the elements myself?

Yes, with the breaker off and the wires tested dead. Take the wires off each element and check from each terminal to bare tank metal. Any reading means that element is shorted. The heating element page walks through it.

Related

Keep going