Furnace heat exchanger: signs of a crack and what to do
The heat exchanger keeps the fire and the exhaust on one side and the air you breathe on the other. A cracked one is a safety problem, not a DIY repair. Here is what to watch for.
- Who fixes it
- A licensed pro
- Typical pro cost
- $1,000–$3,000
- Typical installed cost. Compare with a new furnace
Combustion safety. Confirming a crack takes a professional inspection, and replacing a heat exchanger means taking much of the furnace apart. Licensed pros only.
What it does
What the heat exchanger does
The heat exchanger is the big metal core in the middle of the furnace. The burners fire into it. Hot combustion gases travel through its sealed passages, heating the metal, and leave through the flue.
The blower pushes house air across the outside of that hot metal. The air picks up the heat and goes to your vents. The two never mix.
That wall of metal is what keeps exhaust, including carbon monoxide, out of the air you breathe. A crack or hole in it can let those gases into the house air.
Why it fails
Every heating cycle, the metal heats up and expands, then cools and shrinks. After years of cycles, the metal can weaken and crack.
Overheating speeds that up a lot. A clogged air filter, blocked vents, closed dampers or a failing blower leave the heat exchanger running too hot. That is why a cheap filter change protects the most expensive part in the furnace.
Moisture is the other cause. It corrodes the metal over time. A furnace that is the wrong size for the house, or that short cycles, also puts extra stress on it.
Symptoms
Signs the heat exchanger is failing
CO alarm goes off
A carbon monoxide alarm sounding while the furnace runs is the most serious sign. Get everyone out and call 911 from outside.
Flames jump when the blower starts
Watch the burner flames through the sight glass as the blower comes on. If they float, bend or roll out the moment it starts, that can be a sign of a heat exchanger problem. A pro checks for other causes too.
Soot inside the furnace or nearby
Soot on the furnace, around the burner area or on nearby walls can mean combustion gases are going where they should not.
Rust or flame marks
Heavy rust or flame marks on the furnace are a reason to have the heat exchanger inspected for cracks or rust holes. Do not poke at it.
Headaches or nausea at home
Headaches, dizziness, nausea, tiredness or shortness of breath that ease when you leave the house, especially if more than one person feels it. These can be early carbon monoxide symptoms.
Overheating and short cycling
The furnace runs a few minutes and shuts off on high temperature, again and again. Overheating stresses the heat exchanger. Fix the airflow problem before it causes damage.
Full diagnosis
Safety first
Stay safe until it is fixed
- 1
CO alarm going off? Get out
Get everyone, pets included, into fresh air and call 911 from outside. Do not go back in until emergency responders say it is safe.
- 2
Suspect a crack? Switch it off
Turn the furnace off at its service switch and leave it off until a pro has inspected it.
- 3
Smell gas? Leave first
Do not light anything, touch electrical switches or use a phone inside. Leave right away and call your gas supplier from outside. If you cannot reach them, call the fire department.
What a pro does
What to expect from the service call
- Look over the furnace for rust, soot and flame marks, and watch the burner flames as the blower starts.
- Inspect the heat exchanger itself. A crack can be hard to see, so a full inspection may mean taking parts of the furnace apart.
- Look for the reason it failed, such as poor airflow or a furnace that is the wrong size, so a new one does not fail too.
- If it is cracked, shut the furnace down and quote a heat exchanger replacement or a new furnace. Cracked heat exchangers are replaced, not patched.
- Check the warranty. Heat exchangers often carry a longer warranty than the rest of the furnace, but labor is usually not included.
Know your limits
When to call a pro
Stop and call a pro if
- Your carbon monoxide alarm goes off. Get out first and call 911 from outside.
- The burner flames float, bend or roll out when the blower starts.
- You see soot, scorch marks, heavy rust or flame marks on the furnace.
- People in the house get headaches, dizziness or nausea that ease when they leave.
- The furnace keeps shutting off on high temperature and a new filter has not fixed it.
- A tech has told you the heat exchanger is cracked. Get a second opinion if you like, but leave the furnace off in the meantime.
FAQ
Heat exchanger questions
Can a cracked heat exchanger be repaired?
Not safely. A cracked heat exchanger is replaced, not patched. That is a big job, so many people weigh it against a new furnace, especially if the furnace is older.
Should I replace the heat exchanger or the whole furnace?
Start with the warranty. Many heat exchangers are covered for a long time, sometimes only for the original owner or only if the furnace was registered, and labor is usually extra. If the part is covered and the furnace is fairly new, replacing it can make sense. If the furnace is over 15 years old, a new furnace often makes more sense. Our repair or replace calculator can help you think it through.
Is it safe to run a furnace with a cracked heat exchanger?
No. A crack can let carbon monoxide into your home's air. Leave the furnace off until it is fixed or replaced. Keep carbon monoxide alarms on every level of the home and outside sleeping areas, and test them monthly.
How can I prevent heat exchanger cracks?
Keep the air moving. Change the air filter on schedule, keep vents open, and fix a failing blower motor or repeated overheating quickly. Have the furnace inspected once a year.
Related
Keep going
- SymptomFurnace short cyclingThe furnace starts, runs briefly, shuts off, and starts again before the house warms up. A clogged filter is the most common cause. A dirty flame sensor is next.Open guide
- SymptomFurnace making loud or unusual noisesSqueals and grinding usually mean a worn motor or a loose blower wheel. Rattles mean something is loose. Humming points to a motor or capacitor. A boom at start-up is delayed ignition and needs a pro.Open guide
- SymptomFurnace control board blinking an error codeThe light on the control board flashes a code when something fails. Count the flashes, match them to the chart inside the blower door, and write the code down before you reset anything.Open guide
- Furnace partAir filterThe air filter catches dust before it reaches the blower and heat exchanger. A clogged one chokes airflow, makes the furnace work harder and can trip it off on high heat. Check it monthly.Open guide
- Furnace partHigh limit switchThe high limit switch shuts the burners off if the furnace gets too hot. It trips most often because of poor airflow, so check the filter and the blower before you replace it.Open guide
- Furnace partBurner assemblyThe burners mix gas with air and fire a row of flames into the heat exchanger. Dirty or rusty burners cause late, loud ignition and poor flames. Burner work is for a licensed pro.Open guide