WhatsBusted
3D model of a water heater
Symptom

Tankless water heater goes hot, cold, hot? The cold water sandwich

A short burst of cold water between two hot ones is a known quirk of tankless heaters. Some of it is normal, and much of the rest comes down to flow.

Check these first

Five-minute checks, no tools

  • Only after a pause?

    A few seconds of cool water when you turn the hot back on right after shutting it off is normal for a tankless heater. Try leaving the water running while you lather up and see if it goes away.

  • Open the hot side further

    Low-flow showerheads and faucets set to a trickle can fall below the heater's minimum flow. Turn the handle further to the hot side, or run more hot water, and see if the temperature holds.

  • Test for crossover

    Turn the heater off, close the cold water valve under it, open the hot taps it feeds and wait about 5 minutes. Any water still running, even a trickle, means cold is getting into the hot side, often at a single-handle valve or a crossover valve under a sink. Open the valve again when you are done.

  • Inlet filter and aerators clean

    A clogged inlet screen on the heater cuts flow to the whole house. A clogged aerator or showerhead cuts flow at one fixture. Clean whichever one matches.

  • Recirculation system?

    If your house has a recirculation pump or a crossover valve under a far sink, note it. A valve stuck open there lets cold water into the hot line.

Likely causes

Ranked by how often they are the problem

  1. 1

    Normal start-up delay

    DIY fix

    A short burst of cool water only when you turn the hot back on soon after shutting it off. The heater takes a few seconds to start, so some of this is normal. A small buffer tank on the hot outlet, fitted by a plumber, can smooth it out.

  2. 2

    Flow too low at the fixture

    DIY fix

    The water goes cold in the middle of use at one low-flow fixture or at a trickle. The flow drops below the heater's minimum and it shuts off. Open the tap further, clean the aerator or showerhead, or check the heater's minimum flow in the manual.

  3. 3

    Crossover at a mixing valve or recirculation valve

    DIY fix

    Water keeps running from a hot tap during the crossover test, or one shower or faucet is worse than the rest. A worn single-handle cartridge or a stuck crossover valve is letting cold water into the hot line.

  4. 4

    Clogged inlet filter

    DIY fix

    Hot water flow is weak at every tap. A screen packed with sediment cuts the flow through the heater, which can push it toward its minimum.

    Fix the inlet filter15–30 min$5–$30
  5. 5

    Scale in the heat exchanger

    DIY fix

    Hard water, a heater that has not been flushed in a long while, and temperature swings that keep getting worse. Mineral buildup can upset the heater's sensors and heat transfer. A descaling flush is the fix.

    Fix the descaling1.5 hr–2.5 hr$10–$50
  6. 6

    Flow sensor

    DIY fix

    The heater cuts in and out even at a strong, steady flow, with a clean filter and no crossover. A sensor with debris in it, or one that is failing, can lose track of the flow.

    Fix the flow sensor45 min–1.5 hr$25–$65

What's happening

What your water heater is doing

A tankless heater only heats while water flows through it. When you turn the hot water off, the heater stops. Turn it back on a minute later and the hot water still sitting in the pipe comes out first, then the water that went through the heater while it was starting up, then hot water again.

That middle slug of cool water is the cold water sandwich. The heater needs a few seconds to sense the flow and start heating, so the effect cannot be removed completely on a tankless heater. It should be short and only happen after a pause.

If the water also turns cold in the middle of a shower with no pause, look at flow. A fixture that draws very little water can drop below the flow the heater needs to stay on, so the heater shuts off and starts again.

Cold water can also leak into the hot line after the heater, through a worn single-handle valve, a washing machine connection or a recirculation crossover valve. That is called crossover, and it can cool the water or keep the heater from firing.

Know your limits

When to call a pro

Stop and call a pro if

  • The crossover test shows cold water getting into the hot line and you cannot find which fixture or valve is doing it.
  • You want a buffer tank added to the hot outlet to smooth out the start-up delay.
  • The heater also shows an error code that keeps coming back.
  • You are not comfortable replacing a shower or faucet cartridge.

FAQ

Common questions

Is the cold water sandwich normal on a tankless water heater?

A short one after a pause is. The heater needs a few seconds to start, and that cannot be removed completely on a tankless unit. Cold spells in the middle of steady use are not normal and point to flow or crossover.

How do I get rid of the cold water sandwich?

Keep the water running instead of switching it off and on, use the hot side at a steady flow, and keep the inlet filter and aerators clean. A plumber can add a small buffer tank on the hot outlet to blend away the cold slug.

What is crossover in plumbing?

Cold water getting into the hot line after the water heater. It usually happens at a worn single-handle valve, a washing machine connection or a recirculation crossover valve under a sink. It cools the hot water and can confuse a tankless heater.

Related

Keep going

Get the next fix before it breaks

A short email when the seasons turn: filters to change, detector batteries to check, and new repair guides. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

We send it with Kit. Privacy